BatesLine

« Palm Sunday Choral Evensong | Main | Keeping vigil with Terri »

Terri Schiavo: Out of legislative options?

I'm seeing conflicting information about the status of legislative efforts to prevent the starvation execution of Terri Schiavo, which will begin, by order of Pinellas County, Florida, Judge George Greer, at 1 p.m. Eastern Time today.

The U. S. House passed a bill (HR 1332) on Wednesday that would give a Federal court an opportunity to review the facts of such cases. According to the Tampa Tribune, a unanimous consent request to hear the bill in the Senate failed because of the objection of Oregon Sen. Ron Wyden, a pro-death advocate. The newspaper reported that the Senate succeeded later in passing a private relief bill applying only to Terri, but by then the House had recessed for the month. There's talk of reconvening the House, but many members have already gone back to their districts. Blogs for Terri still seems to hope that this is possible.

Meanwhile the Florida Senate defeated a bill, by a vote of 21-16, which would have set a higher standard for withdrawing food and water from a PVS patient -- there must be either a written advance directive from the patient, or clear and convincing evidence of the patient's wishes. Nine Republicans voted with the Democrats to stop the bill.

As I've said before -- local and state elections matter to the cause of protecting human life. Primary elections matter to the cause of protecting human life. Terri's situation is the result of an elected judge who rejects crucial evidence, the elected sheriff and district attorney of Pinellas County, who refuse to intervene in an apparent case of abuse and neglect, and the Florida legislature, which passed legislation about five years ago categorizing food and water as "life-extending" treatment. Don't assume that if your state legislator is Republican that he's on the right side of this issue.

Comments (2)

Kirk Bjornsgaard:

How can conservatives support government intrusion (by ANY government---state, local, or federal)into a private family matter?

What happened to the conservative/Repuiblican mantra of small, non-intrusive government?

It's hypocrisy as usual for the neocons.

David Adams:

Terri's situation is the result of an elected judge who rejects crucial evidence

I found this interview with the 2003 court-appointed guardian for Terri to be very interesting in regard to the issues you bring up:
http://www.realcities.com/mld/krwashington/11175622.htm

eXTReMe Tracker

About

This page contains a single entry from the blog posted on March 18, 2005 12:08 AM.

The previous post in this blog was Palm Sunday Choral Evensong.

The next post in this blog is Keeping vigil with Terri.

For the latest entries, visit the main page, which also has links to archives by month and by category.

Contact

E-mail: blog AT batesline DOT com

BlogAds

Blog Ad Swap

Support BatesLine

Show your appreciation and help fund hosting and research expenses:

BatesLine is PayPal Verified